Membership STILL In Decline? …. O.K., GOOD!

Reported yesterday at the East Village was an all too common story- one telling the story of the continuing decline in membership of our gentle Craft. What struck me as I read the piece this afternoon, was not so much the fact that yes, our numbers have absolutely declined since the mid 20th century- rather; I am not only in awe these days of not only the former glory of the Temples and Masonic structures of yesteryear, but more so of their present day state of decay and neglect. Even more troubling, that these now unmanageable buildings should have anything at all to do with the current state of Freemasonry!

Simply put, our institution of today couldn’t be any farther from the Institution that occupied the famed Masonic Temple of Detroit than if that building were on the moon.

We are NO LONGER an Institution of massive numbers, marching in parades, and requiring building to house thousands of Masons in Lodge assembled. And- this is a GOOD THING!

Where once a Fraternity existed which accepted nearly everyone who applied, and these applications after World War II were indeed plentiful; we are now an Organization that possesses a much smaller though progressively staunch group of Masons. In my estimation- and please don’t take this as me “not caring” about or “not wishing for” the glory days of the 1910’s-1950’s over again. This is simply not the case, I am only trying to work with what I have to work with, and it would seem that a stronger Institution might be gained through this process of counting our supposed losses.

With proper investigation and vetting, I am confident that the Masons of today could be perhaps more in tune with their “Inner Sanctums and Temples” which they possessed in their souls than were our Brethren of 50 years ago; who may have been more concerned with the grandeur of the structure(s) which housed their “Masonic Temple” and other Appendant Bodies.

Masonic Temple Detroit at

Now, this is not to say that all of our past Brethren were concerned ONLY with the magnificent Temples that they were members of, I would point to any number of Masonic authors from this time period as being incredibly interested with the religion of Masonry. But, it is also important to note that in many cases, as is often the case today, many Masons only joined to be in the Fraternity, and might not have cared so much for the esoteric finer points of our teachings. Even still, these monster buildings and memberships DID exist and flourish. It may be noteworthy to point out that such Temples in large metropolitan areas often housed many different Lodges. Such is still the case at Freemason’s Hall in Indianapolis, where no less than 10 “Blue Lodges” and the Indiana Grand Lodge assembles. Even the Temple of all Temple’s, The Detroit Masonic Temple, housed 8 Blue Lodges and 1 Shrine at its opening in 1926!

What is my point?

Quite frankly, Masonry resides in Men’s Hearts, as is taught in our Lecture(s). This narrative is repeated over and over again and we hear it perhaps hundreds if not thousands of times throughout our Masonic lives… and yet- we FORGET this one, simple, fact.

The ONLY Temple that Masonry really needs is the hearts of Masons!

In this way, we must be able to refine and make do with smaller memberships, smaller buildings, and lower overhead. If we remember that, at the heart of things, all we really do need is to be AT THE HEART OF THINGS; and as such- the building… the Brick and Mortar Temple… is no longer needed. We have individual Masons, who are to become Living Stones in Eternity for that House not made with hands. Why then- do we require a house made with hands while still here on Earth? The answer is- that we do not.

Even still, we see articles written decrying the failing membership of the Fraternity and this is in some way saying that our Institution is nearly doomed. I say that, if we continue to strengthen our ranks with Petitioners to the Craft that will enrich and embolden it, then a lower membership tally will only produce a thinner, shorter, and yet STRONGER wall of Masons- of Living Stones!

With all of that said, and I didn’t start out to say that much, here is the article describing some of our historic structures. As you look through the pictures, and imagine what it must have been like in the heyday 1900’s of Freemasonry. I ask you to also remember that in those times, any one Mason might have been incredibly envious to know that you, here in the present day, might enjoy educational and instructional resources via the World Wide Web that he could have only imagined in his wildest dreams!

As this thought process occurs- ask yourself which you might rather possess. A temporal yet grand Masonic Temple, or an absolutely grand and eternal Masonic Heart?

From the

By Jan Worth-Nelson

Downtown Flint’s Masonic Temple is not for sale, according to Judy Jones, the Temple manager. “We’d like to squelch those rumors,” she said in late January.

But John Porritt, president of the Flint Masonic Temple Association board, said while the longtime downtown landmark is not for sale “at this time,” the matter has been under consideration because “our income is less than our expenses.”

Flint’s Masonic Temple is a designated “Michigan Historic Site”

And sources who asked not to be named said at least one realtor had turned down a chance to represent the building, and several tentatively interested parties have done walkthroughs of the historic building at the corner of Saginaw and East Fourth streets.

Members of the one remaining lodge providing coordinating activities and income to the building, Fellowship Lodge 236, are hoping a fundraising drive this spring might buy them at least another year.

Lodge 236 “Master Mason” Todd Lamb of Flint is leading the drive, and says the group, which has about 225 members, will try to galvanize around hiring a fulltime marketing manager to promote use of the space for weddings, receptions and other public community uses.

It costs about $120,000 a year to keep the doors open, Lamb said. Members pay annual dues of $125 each, though some lifetime members have been relieved of that duty. Since the Masons are a charitable organization, their ability to contribute to the community could be compromised by having to cover the overhead on the property.

Lamb, a regional sales manager for Emerson Electric, said the decline of membership and financial support has been hit with a triple whammy in Flint: the slow slide of General Motors out of town, the related decrease in the city’s population, and the movement of membership-rich lodges to the suburbs.

And of course, the popularity of membership in fraternal organizations in general has declined among the younger generations, Lamb noted.

At its peak in the Sixties, upwards of 5,000 members in a dozen Masons organizations made use of the Temple, he said. Members have included Walter Chrysler, J. Dallas Dort, C.S Mott, James Whiting and many others.

He said the latest blow to the building’s future came when Fellowship Lodge 23, the oldest lodge in Genesee County and one of only two regularly meeting and contributing income to the Temple, disbanded in December. Flint 23 received its charter in 1855, the same year Flint incorporated as a city, he said.

The only active remaining lodge using the Temple is Fellowship Lodge 236.

These unsettled prospects leave Larry Battiste, owner of the legendary Temple Dining Room, uncertain about his own future and the future of his staff and the restaurant which is celebrating its 70th anniversary this year.

Battiste, whose grandparents opened the dining room in 1947, leases his space in the Masonic Temple. He said he thinks there is untapped potential for use of the facility.  He said he hopes the Masonic board will “stay positive” about the options.

“They will have to do what’s right just for them,” Battiste said, coming off a busy 11 a.m. to 2 p.m. weekday lunch shift in the basement eatery. Asked if he would consider going with the Lodge if they go elsewhere, he said it would depend what they offered.

The Masonic Temple at East Fourth and Saginaw streets was dedicated in 1911.

Acknowledging that his business has dropped off over the years as downtown traffic and tastes have changed and his customer base has aged and passed on, he said he also is limited by the outdated aspects of the kitchen.

“We’re running an inefficient operation down here,” he said, “it’s old and inefficient but… it’s what we know. “

His catering business continues to bring in sustaining income, and he has considered doing that full-time if the Temple is sold, but Battiste, who is 63, said, “I’m older now and I don’t have the energy I once did.”

He is assisted in the dining room by his daughter, Christine O’Brien, who said she sees the temple facility as an economical and attractive locale for weddings and other events. Both she and her brother had their wedding receptions there.

Battiste, whose grandparents ran a popular restaurant named Courtavon (at Court and Avon streets) before coming to the Temple, remembers his grandfather sitting him up on a stool as a little boy and letting him make donuts.

He took over management of the dining room in the mid-Seventies, and it’s been his work life ever since.

Regardless of what happens, Battiste said, putting his hand on his heart, the Temple “has given me a good life.”

Lamb noted the difficult decision-making swirling around the Temple now “speaks to a broader concern” — the decline of fraternal organizations in general, and the consequent loss of their benefits to the community.

He noted the Masons regionally had in the last four years alone contributed about $120,000 to Flint community causes – the largest chunk, $100,000, donated to the Community Foundation of Greater Flint fund for the Flint Child Health and Development Fund in response to the water crisis.

In addition, Flint Masons have contributed $2,500 a year to the Flint Public Library in support of literacy development, Lamb said, noting that historically the Freemasons were among early and ongoing supporters of public education in the country.

“When you lose something like that, it has a ripple effect on the community, particularly a community in decline,” Lamb said, “That removes value in a lot of different ways — not to mention the building itself has been a fixture of the downtown landscape for its entire life.”

Construction of the current Temple began in 1908 and the four-story ediface was dedicated in 1911. Lamb said he is interested in historic preservation issues and hopes to explore funding in that direction.

Lamb said some Masons think the battle already has been fought, but he’s not ready to give up.

“We gotta exercise this plan and if in doing it, we fail, we’ll have to take other actions. Those actions could result in us staying in the building and could result in other players in the downtown landscapes participating with us,“ he said.

Lamb appealed on behalf of the building, asking anyone interested in helping preserve the building and keeping it available for the community’s benefit to contact him at

The Masons, also called the Freemasons, are a worldwide fraternal organization with medieval roots. Some say Freemasonry began as a guild for actual stonemasons, but over the centuries, according to Wikipedia, it evolved into a social organization, sometimes based on Christian texts and sometimes more secular – for centuries banning women from their meetings and cultivating secret rituals.

Often seemingly shrouded in secrecy, more recent incarnations of the organization have removed or modified their restrictions, according to Lamb.

“We are not a secret society. We’re a society with secrets,” he said — most involving handshakes and passwords.”

Work with what we have to work with Brethren, for it is all that we have in this moment,           and ’tis best to make do! ~Jon Patrick Sage